Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row vs Archer Pull Up

Which one fits your Back workout plan?

Contents

Planfit users log Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row more often — 455 sessions vs 11. Compare Back form, muscles worked, and when to use each.

Compare the benefits of Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row and Archer Pull Up and pick the one that fits your Back workout.

Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row vs Archer Pull Up: Which Do Planfit Users Choose?

Based on randomly selected data from 1 million completed workouts, Planfit users log Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row more often — 455 sessions compared to 11 for Archer Pull Up.

What most people do isn't always what fits you. Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row and Archer Pull Up differ in the muscles they work, the equipment they need, and how hard they are to learn — the comparison below covers each.

How Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row and Archer Pull Up Differ

What differsUnderhand Smith Machine Barbell RowArcher Pull Up
Equipmenta machinea pull-up bar
Difficulty4 of 55 of 5
Sessions logged by Planfit users455 sessions11 sessions

Related comparisons

Not sure whether Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row or Archer Pull Up fits your goal? Get a personalized plan

How to Do Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row

Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row demo video

Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row Muscles Worked: Back

Form

  1. 1. Please pull towards your belly button so that the barbell can go up vertically.
  2. 2. While bringing your shoulder blades together, naturally pull your elbows and hands.
  3. 3. While holding the weight with your back strength, lower your hands down to below your knees.

Coach's Tips

  1. 1. Please be careful not to let your elbows flare out.
  2. 2. Please be careful not to overly straighten your back or move it up and down.
  3. 3. Engage your core to prevent your back from rounding.

For a full Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row guide with alternatives and benefits, see the Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row exercise guide.

Want to learn more about Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row?Exercise Guide

How to Do Archer Pull Up

Archer Pull Up demo video

Archer Pull Up Muscles Worked: Back

Form

  1. 1. Pull the bar towards your chest while applying strength to one bicep to hold, and push the bar with the other side.
  2. 2. Slowly return to the starting position with your chest relaxed.
  3. 3. Please do the same on the opposite side.

Coach's Tips

  1. 1. Please be careful not to lose your starting position when you come down.
  2. 2. Please make sure your back does not bend excessively.
  3. 3. Please be careful not to use momentum.

For a full Archer Pull Up guide with alternatives and benefits, see the Archer Pull Up exercise guide.

Want to learn more about Archer Pull Up?Exercise Guide

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better for Back, Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row or Archer Pull Up?

Planfit users log Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row more often — 455 sessions against 11 for Archer Pull Up. Both train Back, so pick the one that matches the equipment you have and the muscles you want to load.

What equipment do Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row and Archer Pull Up need?

Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row needs a machine, and Archer Pull Up needs a pull-up bar.

Which is easier to start with?

Underhand Smith Machine Barbell Row is the easier place to start. Move to Archer Pull Up once your form holds up.

Stop Guessing Which One to Do

AI picks your workouts based on your goals, body type, and experience.

Join 4M+ users who found their perfect workout plan

Get Personalized Plans
and More detailed guidance with Planfit

Banner Image